Today marks the anniversary of the ambush and capture of Piers
Gaveston by his deadly enemy, Guy, Earl of Warwick. This was a disaster for Piers, Edward and
enraged Aymer de Valance, into whose custody Piers had been placed.
Here’s a little background information about Pembroke – and his
wives. Aymer de Valence was the second
Earl of Pembroke. He was born in 1275 and was one of the Lords Ordainers who
had ensured that Piers Gaveston was sent into exile for the third time. Pembroke had suffered from Piers sharp
tongue, having been nick-named Joseph the Jew.
The reason was supposedly his appearance. At the time of Piers’ surrender at
Scarborough Castle, Pembroke was married to his first wife, Beatrice, daughter of
Raoul de Clermont, Lord of Nesle
in Picardy (he later married Marie de St
Pol in 1321). Beatrice was to play a
part in the capture of Piers by Guy of Warwick.
In my previous post, I dealt
with the favourable surrender of Piers to Pembroke. It seems both Piers and Edward II were
relieved that Pembroke had custody of Piers.
Pembroke was a man of honour, and had sworn an oath to protect Piers’
life. Whether he had the full support of
the other barons is questionable. He may
have acted without the support of Thomas of Lancaster and Guy of Warwick.
Pembroke decided to take
Piers South. They arrived in Deddington
on June 9th. Piers was housed
in the rectory house at Deddington.
Leaving Piers with some guards, Pembroke headed off to see his wife at
Bampton. It seems incredible that
Pembroke would leave Piers at Deddington and then go on to see his wife. What could be so important that Pembroke
needed to see his wife? And it begs the
question – why didn’t he take Piers with him?
It seems Pembroke decided to make use of the opportunity of being so
near his wife, and possibly he felt Deddington offered more protection to Piers
than his manor house. Or maybe, he was
in contact with Guy of Warwick, and knew that Guy would seize Piers as soon as
Pembroke left. Had Warwick been in
touch, and told Pembroke that he did not have the support of all the Lords
Ordainers, and pressured him into literally handing over Piers? Pembroke used the ‘excuse’ of going to visit
his wife. It seems very unlikely. Pembroke had sworn a chivalric oath, with the
threat of forfeiting his estates. He
had given his word, and ensured Piers and the king were separated. This was a time for negotiation – not to
betray his sovereign, whatever he may have thought of Piers.
How Warwick found out about
Pembroke’s actions remains a mystery. He
must surely have heard Pembroke was in his vicinity. He may have had his men ‘spying’ on what was
happening, keeping him informed of Pembroke’s movements. Or did one of Pembroke’s men betray him? Warwick may have suspected that Pembroke
would visit his wife. Pembroke trusted
his men to guard Piers, and could surely never have guessed his authority would
be challenged. Warwick seized his
chance, and ordered that the guards hand Piers over. We don’t know how many men Pembroke had left
guarding Piers – but it wasn’t enough to protect him. I’ve often wondered why, if he was poorly
guarded, why Piers didn’t plan some sort of escape. However, he had surrendered to Pembroke on
favourable terms, had been treated respectfully by Pembroke, and no doubt felt
safe in his custody. He too had given
his word. Piers was undoubtedly
horrified to be taken by Warwick, and Pembroke was enraged. His honour had been tainted. Warwick’s actions ensured that after the
death of Piers, Pembroke sided with the king from then on. Warwick’s coup was a stain on the Chivalric
code.
Today in Deddington, Piers’
short stay is recognised – there is a Piers Row and Gaveston Gardens.